Quote:
Originally Posted by Aristoddler  If god had doubts about himself, would he be an agnostic?
Nope.
And he could make a rock big enough, sure...but where would he put it?
It would have to be bigger than creation, and that would require him to make something bigger than that which he had already created...which is existence.
|
Why does the rock have to be bigger than creation? Can't its size be small, but its mass large?
Think of a Neutron star, small size, but very large mass.
Is it possible to create something that's mass is greater than creation, but its size is smaller? Yes. It could be the size of a basketball, yet it could be heavier than all creation. Something that size would be able to go anywhere. (As I re-read this it kind of made me think - God could never actually make something heavier than creation, he could only make creation/larger).
However then questions of gravitational pull come in - I'm no physicist so I won't go there.
Anyways - I've always had a problem with this question. It seems nonsensical to me.